I have no idea what ‘Lobakan’ means. I’ve checked both Google and Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia (Indonesian Dictionary) and found nothing about the word, but the words after the colon mean: “A compilation of short stories (The silenced thunderstorm of Bali in ’65).” The number 65 at the end of the title there refers to the year of 1965.
That is the title of the book that I just read.
*edited March 20, 2012 – Just found out from my grandpa that Lobakan is actually a Balinese term for lamp–the old, ancient, petromax lantern. (Doh, I’m such a fake Balinese!)
So, back in December, my grandpa gave me this book Lobakan after I shared with him my interest and findings on one of the darkest history of Indonesia about the PKI (Partai Komunis Indonesia/The Communist Party of Indonesia). After getting enough courage to finally asked him about the incident, my grandpa decided to give me this book ‘if I’m interested.’ (He’s gotta be joking. Of course I’m interested!)
Just in case you have no idea what I’m talking about, here’s a bit of background information based on my findings:
Soekarno, the first president of Indonesia, once proposed a political concept called as ‘Nasakom,’ which literally is an abbreviation of three words: ‘Nasionalisme’ (nationalism), ‘Agama’ (religion), and ‘Komunisme’ (Communism). This is the notion invented by Soekarno as a part of his vision to unite three big political parties existed in Indonesia at that time–PNI (Partai Nasional Indonesia/Indonesian National Party), Islamic parties which were divided into two parties at that time: Masyumi (Partai Majelis Syuro Muslimin Indonesia/Council of Indonesian Muslim Associations) and NU (Nahdlatul Ulama–a traditionalist Sunni Islam group), and PKI (Partai Komunis Indonesia/The Communist Party of Indonesia)–in order to create harmonies between the three, and hence: peace amongst society.
By 1965, the member of the communist party had rapidly increased to 3 million people, and this worried the other 2 parties. Negative sentiments against Soekarno also grew as he supported and protected PKI, along with his ideology as it’s similar with his own.
Long story made short, the tension finally broke by September 30, 1965 as a movement called the 30 September Movement kidnapped several Indonesian war heroes in the army and killed them. Hence, General Soeharto (later the 2nd president of Indonesia) took control and provoked massacre of those known or suspected as “communist allies.” As the army publicly announced that the communists had killed Indonesian respected war heroes to encourage and approve the killings (of the PKI partisans), the Islamic forces did the same thing as they labeled those “communists” as atheists–a word that does not make any sense to most Indonesians, even until now, as Indonesia is not an “atheist country.”
Today it is speculated that the movement was actually a coup d’etat provoked by Soeharto and his army friends, backed by the CIA as they were afraid that Indonesia would become a strong ally to the communist (remember the Cold War?) and the PKI and its “allies” were merely victims of false accusations.
Of course, I might get this wrong, so feel free to correct me.
Here are the links to the sources (most of them, of course, will be Wikipedia):
Okay, enough about history. As my old man put it, “History is about perspective. The more you read, the more you find out.” Well said, grandpa!
Now, aside from the fact of who actually did what, or who was the bad guy, or even who was right or wrong, the thing is that the massacre killed a lot of innocent people. The army encouraged citizens to kill their neighbors, friends, and even family members without trial. And those were the people who might not even know what on earth PKI actually was. Most of them were actually those who merely hired to entertain the actual PKI members in one of their events/propagandas, or hired as a guard during a PKI meeting, and these people are poor peasants who, even if they actually owned the land or the field they were working on, they were really poor that eating rice was considered a luxury for them. Worse, they could even be poor farmers who didn’t even own a land, and merely working on a landowner’s land and gained almost nothing as a result of their hard work. Uneducated people, already suffered, and then suddenly stabbed or even tortured for reasons unknown to them.
Meanwhile, the religious parties (those who does not want to be associated with atheists) also made propaganda as they identify all communist partisans as atheists. They used folklore, myth, legend, belief, and they toyed with people’s faith to encourage the killings. They believed (and I am not referring to a specific kind of religion here because this includes all kinds of religion existed in Indonesia at that time) that killing communists was a religious duty. I am not a big fan of religion so of course I mock this idea. Were I lived during that time, I would definitely be assassinated.
Many believe that at least half a million people died during that time. In one article I read, people were getting used to seeing tons of dead bodies in the river, floating from one village to another village, spreading awful smells of rotten corpses. “No one wanted to risk coming out of the house,” said my grandpa. If I had not mistaken, the biggest killing happened in either East Java and Central Java or Bali, where they said that it was one step closer to become an anarchy.
These are the stories I read in Lobakan. All of them are, of course, fictionalized, because, as I read in the foreword, most of the victims interviewed (or talked to) tried so hard to erase those tragic events from their memories that most of them tried to deflect or even talked about something irrelevant instead of retelling the truth. In the end, no one actually ever find out what actually happened, and I doubt anyone will ever do.
One of my favorite stories is titled Monolog (Monologue), by Putu Fajar Arcana. It contains a speech of one of the victim of the massacre, who told his story of how he got involved with the PKI (although it is not explicitly stated whether he realized and fully acknowledged PKI at all) and later caught and killed. He said he came from a very poor family, whose field were taken by landowners and later were forced into a huge amount of debt by those landowners where in the end they had to work on the land they were supposed to own. The PKI held meetings talking about possibilities to get their land back, and as a poor peasant, how could they say no? The idea alone already seemed like ‘water from the moon’ (meaning impossible) to them. Later, of course, it costed him his life.
Another favorites are Warisan (Legacy) by Putu Satria Kusuma and Menanti Tantri (Waiting for Tantri) by Soeprijadi Tomodiharjo. The first one tells a story about Wayan Guru who was suspected as a PKI partisan and were hiding at his parents’ house while many people were waiting in front of the house, ready to ambush and slay him. His parents told the masses that Wayan Guru was away in Java, yet they waited. At the same time, Wayan Guru begged to see his son, Kadek, who stayed with his wife in his house near his parents’. He was determined to see Kadek, even if it would cost him his life, but his parents asked him to think it through, because death means missing his son’s 3 months ceremony, as well as watching him growing up.
The latter, Menanti Tantri tells a story about Made Arka Wiratma, an activist in fighting against illiteracy, who got a visit from a respectable figure: The governor of Bali, when he was lying sick on a hospital bed, suffering from malaria. His wife who accompanied him at that time was pregnant with his son. The governor suggested to name the unborn child Rai, taken from Balinese war hero: I Gusti Ngurah Rai. To them the visit was such a great honor. Little did they know that the governor was a leftist, and hence, a PKI partisan, as well as what the visit would cost them later.
What’s ironic is how I Gusti Agung Ayu Ratih put it in the foreword about how the government seemed so easily dismissed the tragedy and instead polished the so-called “The island of the gods” with monuments, malls, hotels and clubs to attract investors and tourists from around the world by making the native of this “island of gods” to work (I actually intent to use the work “slavery”) for these visitors who’d see Bali as, indeed, their “heaven on earth.” Try ask the people whether they think it’s a heaven on earth to them.
What? You didn’t expect me to write the complete stories as well as all of the short stories included, right? That wouldn’t be fair to the writers (says the person whose life is devoted to download free stuffs). >:D
I owe my grandpa for willing to give and share this with me, and I love the inscription he wrote on the first page of the book (I always love inscriptions on the first page of my book!) for me:
8 thoughts on “Lobakan: Antologi Cerita Pendek (Kesenyapan Gemuruh Bali ’65)”
As always, I always enjoy reading your stories..
and I’d like to read this book, so would you write the whole story? ha8 :p
I absolutely agree with your grandpa’s statement “History is about perspective. The more you read, the more you find out.” We should also implement it to our lives as well. The more we reflect, the more we find ourselves, what we want, what we need, and what actually important to us. Reading, watching and listening to histories is always amazing, especially getting it from people we really know.
Wow. That’s amazing what you just wrote. And hahaha, if you really want to read the book, I could always send you the book. Just send me your address and it shall be delivered asap ;) Of course, it would even be much easier if you’re closer to where I live right now… if you know what I mean >:)
Another interesting and well-written article, mbak! Have you managed to send a copy to your grandpa? I hope he’ll like it, I definitely would love to get involved in the discussion with you and grandpa about PKI stuff as I heard some stories from my old neighbors about their life in Nusakambangan. To agree with, living the years of G30S had left a huge scar for the witnesses as they even pretended not knowing each other (i’m talking about my neighbors who happened to meet after 23 years, and they used to live in the same prison in Nusakambangan back then).
As you shared that the massacre centered around Bali, Central, and East Java, I wondered if there are other similar anthologies made about the victims from Java. Hahaha
I’m waiting for the next article :D Also if your grandpa writes back, please post it here as well, if you dont mind, of course.
P.S. You should thank to God for letting you live in the present times. You could just be a name of a brutal blogger if you lived during the PKI period. Haha
Haven’t sent it yet, but I’ve called him yesterday and after getting enough courage to ask him to read it, I almost jump to the moon (of course not) when he said yes! Oooohhhh, did you ask about the details to your neighbors? Of course, they might not want to share that, but it’s worth-asking. I believe that there are similar stories from Java. If you’ve read Ahmad Tohari’s Ronggeng Dukuh Paruk, you could probably imagine already. I can’t promise anything about my grandpa response yet, but I promise I’ll keep you updated asap! I’m so excited of the idea of sending him this! And again, yes, I’m grateful that I live in the present days. I couldn’t imagine what it was like living during that time. Those were horrible times, and probably were the darkest days in Indonesian history. :(
Wow, Dian! The story is amazing and very well written. What amazes me the most is the great deal of lessons worth spreading from your work. Lessons that may help us understand the nature of humanity as well to remember the thing we did wrong as species and the difficult consequences. I hope you continue with your work. Wish you best!
Thank you so much, Gustavo! You sure just motivated me to write better and better each time! :)
You didn’t write just another post, it’s a personal, yet very accurate and solid analysis, a well written account of one of the worst crimes against humanity in the second half of last century. And a empathetic review as well.
It should have been, it should still be published as an article in nationwide papers or an essay in weekly or monthly (“www.insideindonesia.org” perhaps?).
It still is! I’m currently opening the link you gave me, and I read several articles related to the event, though mostly related to the movie “The Act of Killing.”